Very interesting reporting again. I was witnessing this myself as my Moments filled up with reposts starting in the afternoon, with many people repeatedly reposting different versions of the same video, clearly out of anger and resistance, often in slightly altered form to avoid detection, and from different Channels accounts, which is something very new and unexpected.
However, do you really have verified sources for these viewership numbers? And for something like the "conference call"?
Why is it surprising? It has been going on since they let that virus loose. Just now the more privileged can slightly speak out. It's nothing new. They welded apt buildings shut since 2020
I am a college student from China. Although I am not in Shanghai, I am in the cities around Shanghai. This video is not very popular in China. Why is it so exaggerated by you?
Personally, I think Shanghai is a failed exploration in the fight against the epidemic. Although there are complaints, it is far less terrifying than what is shown in the video. The background is gray, and at first glance it is a common trick to smear China.
Please report more positive remarks. Why did Shanghai's failure to fight the epidemic become your serious denial of freedom of speech? More encouragement, less scolding. I love my motherland, and I object to your exaggerated description of Shanghai's epidemic prevention.
There is no problem with the government, last year the Chinese government was number one in the world in terms of trust, you can check it out, anyway, I live in mainland China, I think the government is still doing something, otherwise how could the 40 years of reform and opening up have caused the hostility of the United States. This time it is the Shanghai government's slow response that has led to so many cases in Shanghai at the moment.
Are you sure you are commenting on this article? There is nothing about Shanghai's "epidemic prevention" in it. It's about the failed censorship of a video. So what are you objecting to?
You are certainly correct that there are lots of anti-China smear videos on the Internet; we have pointed this out in a number of articles. The video referred to here doesn't look like one of those.
That aside, if there were an epidemic, the bodies would be piling up. The reality is that there are very few deaths due to Covid, and those who did die averaged about 90 years old. Far more people have died due to the lockdown than due to Covid-19. So not only have 300 billion+ yuan in production been obliterated, but more lives were lost than were saved.
Sorry, I hurriedly commented without watching this video, I took it for granted that this video was a smear of China. I am so excited because I love my country so much. I know that the previous clips in this video are the true dark side of the grassroots when the epidemic broke out in Shanghai. I hope that such a tragedy will not be staged in another city in China and the epidemic will end soon.
Hopefully, ‘the people’, can win the next few rounds as well. Then who knows?...
Heartbreaking.
Very interesting reporting again. I was witnessing this myself as my Moments filled up with reposts starting in the afternoon, with many people repeatedly reposting different versions of the same video, clearly out of anger and resistance, often in slightly altered form to avoid detection, and from different Channels accounts, which is something very new and unexpected.
However, do you really have verified sources for these viewership numbers? And for something like the "conference call"?
This is not the kind of thing the Shanghai Daily reports on ;)
Why is it surprising? It has been going on since they let that virus loose. Just now the more privileged can slightly speak out. It's nothing new. They welded apt buildings shut since 2020
Hacker News Comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31150370
I am a college student from China. Although I am not in Shanghai, I am in the cities around Shanghai. This video is not very popular in China. Why is it so exaggerated by you?
Personally, I think Shanghai is a failed exploration in the fight against the epidemic. Although there are complaints, it is far less terrifying than what is shown in the video. The background is gray, and at first glance it is a common trick to smear China.
Please report more positive remarks. Why did Shanghai's failure to fight the epidemic become your serious denial of freedom of speech? More encouragement, less scolding. I love my motherland, and I object to your exaggerated description of Shanghai's epidemic prevention.
China’s government silences its people
There is no problem with the government, last year the Chinese government was number one in the world in terms of trust, you can check it out, anyway, I live in mainland China, I think the government is still doing something, otherwise how could the 40 years of reform and opening up have caused the hostility of the United States. This time it is the Shanghai government's slow response that has led to so many cases in Shanghai at the moment.
Are you sure you are commenting on this article? There is nothing about Shanghai's "epidemic prevention" in it. It's about the failed censorship of a video. So what are you objecting to?
You are certainly correct that there are lots of anti-China smear videos on the Internet; we have pointed this out in a number of articles. The video referred to here doesn't look like one of those.
That aside, if there were an epidemic, the bodies would be piling up. The reality is that there are very few deaths due to Covid, and those who did die averaged about 90 years old. Far more people have died due to the lockdown than due to Covid-19. So not only have 300 billion+ yuan in production been obliterated, but more lives were lost than were saved.
Sorry, I hurriedly commented without watching this video, I took it for granted that this video was a smear of China. I am so excited because I love my country so much. I know that the previous clips in this video are the true dark side of the grassroots when the epidemic broke out in Shanghai. I hope that such a tragedy will not be staged in another city in China and the epidemic will end soon.
Here is a good example of one of those dark sides you mention: https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1010162/he-was-visiting-shanghai.-then-his-health-code-turned-red